Laura ☂ ([info]starryeyedmagic) wrote,
@ 2009-05-20 21:52:00
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend  Next Entry
Current mood: sick
Current music:Neko Case - This Tornado Loves You
Entry tags:health: sick, people: neil patrick harris, picspam, public, ship: barney/robin, tv: how i met your mother

"She could Mosby the crap out of him!"
o1. UGH I AM SO SICK! I didn't work today because I am dying a slow and horrible cold related death. ALAS! *achoo*

o2. I realize that about 117 people have already done picspams of this but I just needed to share my own brand of over-analyzing insanity.



Professor Mosby vs. Missy


+ Animals staring blankly never fails to crack me up
+ THIS SHOW GETS 100 POINTS FOR USING 'MURDER TRAIN' DURING THE FIGHT SCENE.
Why do I not have that mp3? Seriously? My ipod needs some Foreskins for the lulz.
+ OH HAI MOTHER!


Marshall vs The Leap Of Possible Death


+ YOU CAN SEE THE SLUTTY PUMPKIN IN THE LAST CAP IN THE 2ND ROW!
+ Marshall is so wonderful as he prepares to fly over
+ Honestly, that jump looks kind of big. If you didn't make it you wouldn't be like, "oops! I bumped me knee!" you'd be like, "oops! I DIED!" lol.


+ Aw, Barney/Ted! I love the goggles and Ted's blow up guitar, hee!
+ AND GUUUUH NPH!


Barney & Robin vs "The Feelings"


+ Aw, the gang's back together again! I was ok without Lily for about 2 episodes, but then after that it really did feel like there was a hole in the group.
+ Also, wtf Ted? Being a professor at an IVY LEAGUE college is not really a dead end job. You're not teaching 8th grade gym in the projects.
+ 2nd row - Barney laughs and looks directly at Robin. And then once Ted leaves he really looks at her. Like it's almost a stare. I guess he's decided to finally tell her.


Barney: Hey Ted, whatcha doing?
Ted: Designing a building shaped like a hat.
Barney: Now a good time to chat?
Ted: No.
Barney: So what do you think of Robin?
Ted: Barney, I really need to get to work. So...
Barney: Great! Say you and I went suit shopping and you happened upon a beautiful suit...a beautiful Canadian suit. Double breasted, mhmmm! You try it on, but it's not exactly the right fit for you so you put it back. And then I try it on...I don't really want to take the same suit that you had your eye on, but at the same time...I really like that suit.
Ted: Buy the suit, Barney. You clearly care about it. Tell the suit how you feel.


+ I love the Robin = a suit analogy. Double breasted, oh Barney. Even when you're being cute you're being dirty. And that's why I love you.


Barney: Ok. But Ted, remember that was your answer because...the suit is Robin. I know! *exploding gesture* Right?!
Ted: I'm with ya, Buddy!


+ Aw, look at him playing with his tie all nervously and the way he taps Ted on the shoulder. I love that making sure this all ok with Ted is really important to him.
+ heh, I love how Barney really doesn't get how obvious he's been about this entire thing all year.
+ Ted's amused smile at the end is great. He's a great bro.


Barney: You are now. Because I explained it to you.
Ted: What are you...? Don't...
Robin: ...Oh crap!


+ AW HUG! lol don't protest the man love, Ted!
+ *GASP* Robin!

Ok here's the deal with Robin:
I've always been under the impression that she made the first move in 'Sandcastles In The Sand'. She was the one who invited him up to her apartment in the first place to show him something she had never shown anyone else. And just look again at the way she gazed at him while they were watching the vid. That look spoke volumes. And then there's the way she grabbed onto his tie while they were kissing.
Besides, I feel like it would have been kind of out of line for Barney to have made the first move. Sure, he's a cad, but I don't think he'd ever throw himself at his best friend's ex-girlfriend/his friend who had a rough night. But...he's still Barney, so if she threw herself at him, he wouldn't be able to resist.

Afterward she told him to pretend like it never happened. Because it's Barney. It's Barney. He hasn't had anything more than casual sex in over (almost?) a decade. He doesn't do feelings. Therefore if there is any possibility even in the slightest of ways that Robin could feel anything for him...she would want to fix that. Because there would be NO CHANCE WHATSOEVER (or so she would think).

So, I think she's had feelings for him all along. Feelings just as strong as his are for her. But any time she felt them creep up she would just have to tell herself "NO NO NO" and stay in deep denial mode to avoid being hurt. Because being hurt in that situation would be almost inevitable because...it's Barney.

I mean, she denied her feelings for Ted for a long time back in s1 and he was actively pursuing her at the time! Why would she ever admit to herself that she likes someone who pretends to vomit at the mention of anyone's "feelings". Honestly, if I were Robin I think this is exactly what I would have done.

And then when she overhears this conversation...she's in shock. Her own feelings are so buried that she's not even thinking about that. She's just done such a good job at convincing herself that it's not even in the realm of possibility that she just thinks "I NEED TO STOP THIS RIGHT NOW!"
And I'm not sure she even grasps the gravity of what he feels either.


Lily: He said that? Oh my god! What a tremendous, ground breaking surprise!
Robin: How long have you known?
Lily: 8 months!
Robin: And you kept it a secret since then? Good for you!
Marshall: Yea, wow! Good for you, Lily! What a bombshell! Who saw that coming?!
Robin: How long have you known?
Marshall: 7 months, 29 days.


+ heh, Lily kept this from Marshall for 1 whole day! Good for Lily!
+ This also reminds me of Phoebe from Friends saying "THIS IS BRAND NEW INFORMATION!" ha.


Robin: God, what am I going to do?
Lily: I don't know, what are you gonna do?!
Robin: I'm going to marry Barney in a big church wedding! And we're going to move to some sleepy New Hampshire town and open a bed and breakfast!
Marshall & Lily: Awwwww! <333
Marshall: Really?!!
Robin: No!!


+ Marshall is the #1 Barney/Robin shipper ever. Lily is #2.
If you've been looking at my other Barney/Robin picspams over the past few weeks you've noticed how every time Barney tells a joke Marshall's first reaction is to look at Robin to see her reaction. ;)
+ Look at how he is biting his lip in the 2nd cap! And he looks like he's about to cry tears of joy towards the end.
+ I love how M/L clasp hands, THEY ARE THE CUTEST COUPLE EVER! True story.
+ And this is one of the things I most wanted to see in the Barney/Robin storyline and I hope we get tons more of this next season. By "this" I mean the fact that Marshall & Lily aren't going to "get" Barney & Robin's relationship AT ALL. They're not going to understand why they don't do "coupley" things and prefer to remain mocking people who do. ha. (B/R might still go to brunch sometimes though, but JUST FOR THE PANCAKES! BECAUSE PANCAKES ARE DELICIOUS!)
+ Can't you see Lily listing all the things that Barney "can't do" when he eventually starts dating Robin? And then Marshall will make a chart/graph about it (even though he's not supposed to use visual representation of any kind now, tsk!). But Robin will just be like "CHILL GUYS!" because their relationship will never be about "rules". It'll be about what they want to do, not what they can't do.


Robin: It's Barney! I mean, it's Barney. But it's Barney! I gotta tell him no.
Lily: Oh man, you're gonna break his...whatever it is that pumps that black sludge through his veins.


+ heh, Lily!
+ ROBIN, FORGET BARNEY'S HEART! YOU'RE BREAKING MARSHALL'S HEART!
+ Robin's line translation:
"It's Barney" - He's like my best friend. I don't want to ruin that.
"I mean, it's Barney" - He's my best friend. Who I really...who I kind of...
"But it's Barney!" - IT IS BARNEY THE WOMANIZING IDIOT WHO ONLY CARES ABOUT SUITS, BOOBS, AND SCOTCH! HE DOESN'T DO FEELINGS!


Robin: Oh crap, you're right! The first time Barney expresses feelings for a girl and she rejects him? And not just any girl, I mean (points to herself), it'll destroy him.
Marshall: Well, first of all (gestures to Robin) Eh! And second of all, there is a maneuver you can try. It's high risk but it's also high reward. For lack of a better term I'm going to call it...The Mosby.
Robin: The Mosby?
Lily: No, she couldn't Mosby him!
Marshall: She could Mosby the crap out of him!
Robin: What's the Mosby?


+ First of all, I LOVE Robin's line here about thinking she's all that. HA, TRUE STORY! But also, that line is so Barney. Just like the line about waiting for a first bump from Ted was last week.
+ And second of all, Marshall and Lily's REAL plan is that they think when Robin tells Barney she loves him he'll just say "I LOVE YOU TOO!" and then sweep her off her feet and cause her to realize her own secret feelings (that they both know that she has).
I realize that that scenario is the most OOC thing in the history of earth, but remember 2mins ago when Marshall and Lily thought Robin was serious about marrying Barney? lol they ship them so much they're kind of beyond logic. And also, they're such hopeless romantics that they would think that if two people who really loved each other were to say it out loud then that would be enough. How presh. Too bad (and awesome for us) that Barney/Robin aren't like most people.
+ Thirdly, "I mean you're very pretty, but you're freakishly tall, and you don't believe in ghosts!"
OMG MARSHALL, MY LOVE FOR YOU IS ENDLESS! And I love M/L's smug looks after that. ha.


+ I just love the way he looks at her as he prepares to tell her how feels. He almost doesn't have to say it. You can just see it.


+ This was exactly the reaction that she was expecting from him. But not the one she was hoping for. However I don't think she realizes that until she notices how much his reaction really does hurt.
+ You can just see her thinking "ok, there it is! He fell for it!" in the last cap in the 2nd row/first cap in the 3rd row. But then look at her reaction at the very end....she's not faking there. He already turned away.
+ After this scene Robin also disappeared from the party (I was actually looking for her in the background). I think she just had to get out of there and clear her head. I mean, everything she had been trying all year (or possibly longer) to DENYDENYDENY would naturally be beginning to surface. And clearly, after what just happened she would think she was right to have pushed it down in the first place.


+ I love how excited he is here! Both by Robin having feelings for him and the fact that he's been momentarily "CURED" of his debilitating illness. His smile here is so cute, lol he's such an ass. <3
+ Lily is so disappointed. She really thought her plan was going to work. She was so excited at first to see him so happy.


Barney: Why nooooooot?!

+ aww! He's so cute when he whines. ha.


Barney: So, you're in love with me?
Robin: What? Oh, yeah! Very much.
Barney: Ok, you can knock it off, Lily told me!
Robin: Dammit, Lily!
Barney: I can't believe you would do that!


+ Aw, look at them giggling in the first cap!
+ I love Cobie's line reading of "Oh, yeah! Very much!" It cracks me up every time.


Robin: It's just...look, I care about you Barney! And this kind of stuff, the emotional stuff...it's not your thing. I thought I'd save you the trouble.
Barney: Maybe I don't want to be saved the trouble. Maybe I want the trouble. I haven't wanted the trouble in a long time, but with you the trouble doesn't seem so...troubling. I don't know. I thought...I thought you felt the same way.


+ Oh Barney, that is the line of the night.
+ But see, she's still disbelieving that he'd be able to handle the emotional stuff. Despite everything she's heard she's still unconvinced they could ever have anything. His line here kind of shows her that maybe...she was wrong.
+ And Barney even thought that she felt the same way! Aw, look at him looking down, playing with his suit, and thinking he's about to be rejected.


Robin: Maybe I do. I don't know. I'm not exactly the biggest confronter of feelings. But I mean, clearly there's something between us. Maybe my head was saying 'nip it in the bud' cause my heart was saying something else. Look, I have feelings for you, Barney. Maybe I even love you...

+ Wow. I was really just hoping for a glance from her to show that she had feelings for him but this is SO MUCH BETTER.
+ She's being totally honest here. There is no Mosbying going on. I mean, Ted doesn't even Mosby this awkwardly. ha.
+ She can't look him in the eye...and neither can he through most of this. ha, I love how bad they are at this.
+ I really don't think this is coming from nowhere. As I said before, I really think she's felt like this for a long time. But she never allowed her mind to even go there because it just sounds so insane. However I'm sure the night before she had to really think about it for the first time ever.
+ Look at her look down and bite her lip before admitting full on that she has feelings for him.


Barney: Woah! This is going pretty fast, don't you think?
Robin: What?
Barney: We have a really good friendship going, why screw up a good thing? Friends?
Robin: Friends.
Barney: Oh my god, you just did it again! You just Mosby-ed me!
Robin: I did not!
Barney: You did! You little Minsk!
Robin: Ok, you're right. I did just Mosby you.
Barney: Why are you so afraid of giving this a chance?
Robin: Because I am afraid of how much I like you!


+ Ok, this is where the game starts up again. heh. Robin is a bit taken aback at first because she wasn't Mosbying him at all, they were both just being honest. But an emotionally honest conversation? Plz. That can't be allowed to continue. That's not how they ~roll~. So they're going back to the game. And one of them has to win this game. Whatever that means. I don't think they even know.
+ Ah 4th row center, right next to the hand shake! Look at Neil's tongue! Hee!


Barney: Woah, this is a bad idea!
Robin: You're right! This is a mistake!
Barney: Yes. *beat* No!
Robin: I love you!
Barney: Let's be friends!
Robin: Ok! Friends then!
Barney: I love you.
Robin: Let's get married!
Barney: No! You're smothering me!
Robin: Ok! Forget it!
Barney: Aaargh!
Robin: Aaargh!


+ Even they don't know what's going on here. It's mostly not serious...with tiny bits of serious thrown in there.
They both seriously think this is a mistake. They both seriously want each other. So they're simultaneously trying to scare off the other person and trying to keep the conversation going.
+ You know what I love about them? That's it's always been a game. Even on the viewer's part. The way they sit next to each other, the way they laugh at each other's jokes, the glances, the touches...you have to be really observant to catch most of what makes Barney/Robin what they are. It's like a totally different kind of viewing experience that makes me appreciate the entire show in a different way.
But I'm sure most people aren't watching like that. So while those viewers would still enjoy this resolution, they wouldn't enjoy it as much as the "crazies" will.


.........

+ I WILL NOT APOLOGIZE FOR THE AMOUNT OF CAPS!
+ There are no duplicates though, each one is different in a really big way, I swear!
+ guuuuh that kiss is really intense. I love that they both just became so exasperated with the situation that they just poured all of that frustration into each other. And their hands are everywhere. Even in her hair!
+ I love that his hand is tangled in her hair in the middle cap in the 2nd to last row
+ And that the kiss was so messy that they're wiping their mouths, ha.
+ MORE AVOIDING! heh, I love them. But at least they're both on the same page now.


+ "Oh we didn't just make out at the hospital? What?"
+ In the first cap you can see Robin playing with her hair and staring off into space. I wonder what she's thinking about, hmm? ;)
+ Barney is...updating his private blog? He needs to write down what he's feeling RIGHT NOW.
+ heee, BARNEY WANTED TO PLAY THE VIOLIN!
+ Aw, the little smile in the first cap in the 2nd row


+ And again, DOESN'T THAT JUMP LOOK HUGE?! Maybe it's not meant to though. I mean, obviously they all did it easily enough.
+ Aw, I love the Robin/Marshall high five!


+ This was one of my favorite moments of the entire episode.
+ Look at his tongue sticking out a little as he's about to jump. Aw!
+ He looks a little nervous for a second, and then he looks at her and those fears just melt away. LOOK AT THAT LOOK IN THE SECOND ROW. Just...wow. <3
+ hee, he stumbles a bit at first and falls over.
+ And then she runs to give him a hug and Marshall squees his brains out!


+ AW GROUP HUG! I love them all.
+ At the end Barney and Robin are about to hug again and Marshall's about to squee again!



Oh gosh, I can't wait for all the sex Barney and Robin are going to have next season. It'll be ridiculous and Marshall/Lily/Ted are all going to be disgusted. \o/

In this interview about the season finale Neil talks about how he would never let Barney/Robin become one of "those" couples like on Mad About You who are obsessed with diapers and whatnot.

I wouldn't worry. That wouldn't just be OOC for him, it'd be OOC for her too. Anyone who's worried about that clearly isn't that big a fan of the show.

As much as Barney and Robin love and adore their friends they'd probably kill themselves before their relationship became anything like the relationships Marshall/Lily/Ted want/have. I mean, that's why Robin and Ted broke up in the first place. It's not her thing.

Barney and cigars and scotch and sex (and guns). Those are her things.

They'll just be awesome and in love and over-sexed.

This is where the fun really starts. I can think of about 30 different hilarious and awesome Barney/Robin storylines off the top of my head that don't involve anything traditional. I think it'll be a new venture for television to have a couple like this.

They'll be the anti-couple.

Previous Barney/Robin picspams:
4.14 - The Possimpible
4.18 - Old King Clancy
4.19 - Murtaugh
4.20 - Mosbius Designs
4.21 - The Three Days Rule + 4.22 - Right Place, Right Time
4.23 - As Fast As She Can

UP NEXT: PICSPAM OF THIS SEASON FROM ROBIN'S POV


o3. Neil & David are the most adorable couple in the history of earth.


Page 1 of 2
<<[1] [2] >>

(73 comments) - (Post a new comment)


[info]meesters
2009-05-21 09:50 am UTC (link)
Oh, baby, I hope you feel better soon! I just recovered from some nasty cold myself, so I'm feeling your pain *hugs*

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]starryeyedmagic
2009-05-21 06:06 pm UTC (link)
Thanks! I'm glad to hear you're feeling better too!

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]woodycakes
2009-05-21 10:19 am UTC (link)
this was such an epic spam. i don't know how you do it. but i feel like i've analyzed the show along with you and i haven't even seen it. amazing analysis :D can't wait for next season's hopefully lovefest :)

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]starryeyedmagic
2009-05-21 06:28 pm UTC (link)
I can't wait to hear what you think when you actually see it then, haha!

Yes, s5 will hopefully be all Barney/Robin sex all the time!

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]ikilledkenny86
2009-05-21 10:55 am UTC (link)
Aww *hug* feel better! :)

This pic!spam is epic.

I WILL NOT APOLOGIZE FOR THE AMOUNT OF CAPS!


NEVER!

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]starryeyedmagic
2009-05-21 06:29 pm UTC (link)
Thanks!

haha, it's the first time they've made out in over a year. Of course I'm going to put up every .5 seconds of it!

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]singingrl
2009-05-21 05:26 pm UTC (link)
I love your analysis of HIMYM, you focus on Barney/Robin far more than I do lol, but I totally ship it *g* and this pic spam was epic :)

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]starryeyedmagic
2009-05-21 06:32 pm UTC (link)
I just think both of their characters and their relationship are so unique. Usually when two people get together it's like "What's next?" and it becomes boring after like 3 episodes. But I feel like with them the most interesting parts of the story won't even happen until they're "together" (in whatever capacity). They're like the anti-couple or something. I think it'll be hilarious.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]ac_lovebug
2009-05-21 07:12 pm UTC (link)
aww get better soon!! =)

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]starryeyedmagic
2009-05-21 09:54 pm UTC (link)
Thanks! I'm sure I'll be all right in a day or two.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]areasontofight
2009-05-21 10:27 pm UTC (link)
THIS PICSPAM IS EPIC. I have to go watch the episode again...

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]starryeyedmagic
2009-05-21 10:57 pm UTC (link)
You do! It is rather epic itself!

I need next season now!

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]her_lovelyheart
2009-05-21 10:31 pm UTC (link)
+ heee, BARNEY WANTED TO PLAY THE VIOLIN!
THAT WAS THE CUTEST BIT EVER!!!!!!!!! I can't believe no one else mentioned it in their picspams so points to you!

And awesome awesome picspam! This finale was everything all my other season finales WEREN'T! Thanks for the pretty. Adding to Mems. ♥

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]starryeyedmagic
2009-05-21 11:13 pm UTC (link)
Seriously, that was beyond adorable. It was so typical for him almost. I feel like he has all these secret little passions that he never tells anyone about.
That's another great thing that next season can bring. Robin might discover tons of secret things about him that he'd never dare tell anyone. heh.

ikr? This season finale was actually HAPPY!

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)(Expand)

(no subject) - [info]her_lovelyheart, 2009-05-21 11:27 pm UTC (Expand)

[info]spuffy_girl
2009-05-21 10:36 pm UTC (link)
I loved the episode and your amazing pic!spam.

After multiple viewings of the last scene (and not just for the song, which I love), I decided that I'd be too terrified to jump to the next building. And if I did, I'd definitely fall. And then there'd be no way back over if I made it.

Marshall and Lily are the biggest BroTP shippers ever. I really hope Ted starts shipping them soon.

I loved Barney with the violin. That was adorable.

The hospital scene was great.

Adding to memories.

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]starryeyedmagic
2009-05-21 11:19 pm UTC (link)
I love the song too. I should go hunt for the mp3. Do you know the name of it?

I guess the buildings were closer together than they seemed, and the other one was slighter lower so it only...looked scary. That's what I'm assuming. Because otherwise it seems kind of insane, lol. Like I get the metaphor, but I doubt Ted would want to leap into another career if he or one of his friends accidentally DIED! woops!

I think Ted does ship them. He's been pretty smiley about it thus far. I think he'll be happy. He just probably won't cry about it like Marshall, haha!

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)(Expand)

(no subject) - [info]spuffy_girl, 2009-05-21 11:21 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]starryeyedmagic, 2009-05-22 12:19 am UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]spuffy_girl, 2009-05-22 12:31 am UTC (Expand)

[info]goldy_dollar
2009-05-21 11:17 pm UTC (link)
Awww, loved this picspam and the episode!! I only just saw it last night, so it was great to be able to relive it. :D

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]starryeyedmagic
2009-05-21 11:27 pm UTC (link)
Thanks, it was such an AWESOME episode!

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]katayla
2009-05-22 12:59 am UTC (link)
Hope you feel better! And I'm always up for new picspams from you. :) (ESPECIALLY THE ROBIN-CENTRIC ONE!)

Honestly, that jump looks kind of big. If you didn't make it you wouldn't be like, "oops! I bumped me knee!" you'd be like, "oops! I DIED!" lol.

Lol, I kept going, "Noooo! Don't do it, Marshall!" I mean, obviously, the finale wasn't going to end with all of them DYING, but in real life, no way would I be convinced to make that jump!

Oooh, here's a thought: Has Barney EVER had meaningful sex? Because he and Shannon were waiting, and it's not like he's had any serious girlfriends since then. No wonder Robin messed him up so much!

Haha, I was so glad we found out Lily only kept it from Marshall for a day. I KNEW she had to tell him everything! They've so been analyzing B/R as much as we have all season long.

I interpreted the "It's Barney" lines the same way. You can really see Robin's denial in that scene. She wants him! She does! She just can't figure out how it could work.

And the KISSING! I can't wait until next season when we get this (and sex) ALL THE TIME!

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]starryeyedmagic
2009-05-22 03:29 am UTC (link)
Around dinner tonight I started feeling a bit better, thanks!

Oh wow, that is a really interesting thought. You're right, I don't think he's ever had sex with anyone he actually cared about before. It's almost like Robin took away his "feelings" virginity or something, ha.

You know, I feel like I could write a whole thesis on Barney & Robin, haha. I mean, they're just really psychologically fascinating to me.

They've so been analyzing B/R as much as we have all season long.
Oh gosh, I started working on the Robin-picspam tonight and I was looking at caps from "The Fight". Marshall is like analyzing Robin's every move while she's all over Barney. HA! I remember looking at Lily's reaction to them back then but not at his because I wasn't sure he knew. Oh my. I need to watch the whole season again from a new perspective.

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)(Expand)

(no subject) - [info]katayla, 2009-05-22 04:29 am UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]starryeyedmagic, 2009-05-22 01:59 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]katayla, 2009-05-22 07:21 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]starryeyedmagic, 2009-05-22 07:46 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]katayla, 2009-05-22 08:33 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]starryeyedmagic, 2009-05-22 11:18 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]katayla, 2009-05-23 12:08 am UTC (Expand)

[info]the_spin
2009-05-22 01:00 am UTC (link)
Dude, this is like the most awesome thing ever! I agree whole-heartedly with so much of your commentary; I'm so with you on the canon-support for Robin harboring feelings for Barney that's she's basically denialed into oblivion because a.) she hates being that vulnerable in the first place and b.)can't even imagine him wanting a relationship. The 'it's Barney' scene I thought was such a perfect, subtle way for them to show that. Like, she had a moment of introspection and considered saying yes for 2.5 seconds before her rational side shut it down.

I mean, the end of Shelter Island? That was such a move on her part. And the way she's like so relieved and happy to see him when he opens the door? Yeah Scherbatsky, not at all obvious.

By "this" I mean the fact that Marshall & Lily aren't going to "get" Barney & Robin's relationship AT ALL. They're not going to understand why they don't do "coupley" things and prefer to remain mocking people who do.

This is what I'm most excited for during the inevitable Barney/Robin. It's going to confuse and frustrate poor Marshall and Lily so much, and it's going to be hilarious. Like, I hope they do an episode at some point that inverts all the stuff from 'The Slutty Pumpkin.' It would be such a great opportunity for callbacks, and a great way to extend the show's whole 'there's more than one way to be in love with someone' thesis from 'Three Days of Snow.'

Thanks for the awesome picspam!

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]starryeyedmagic
2009-05-22 04:51 am UTC (link)
You're so right about Shelter Island! I feel like she just had a kind of crappy long day(she even says that) so at that moment she was just like "fuck it" and wanted to do something that would make her happy (spending the night with Barney) regardless of the consequences. Her defenses were down right then and she didn't care about all the reasons it didn't make sense.

Oh yes, definitely. I kind of hope that 'there's more than one way to be in love with someone' will be a major storyline all throughout s5. It'd be wonderful of them to show that Marshall & Lily's relationship isn't the only kind of successful relationship you can have.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]sellega
2009-05-22 01:58 am UTC (link)
I LOVE ALL OF THIS.

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]starryeyedmagic
2009-05-22 05:09 am UTC (link)
THANKS! :D

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]fallintospace
2009-05-22 02:36 am UTC (link)
THIS IS THE BIGGEST MOST WONDERFUL SPAM EVER. I seriously have had this open for about an hour looking/reading it off/on. Now I must watch again and notice all these things.

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]starryeyedmagic
2009-05-22 05:19 am UTC (link)
THANKS! Yea, what I love about Barney/Robin's whole relationship is that there's so many things that you don't notice on your first viewing. So when you go back and look at it you're like "...wait!"
I mean, think about how we didn't know that Marshall knew about Barney's feelings for the entire season! I bet he was looking for Robin's reaction to Barney even before I noticed it.
And now that I'm thinking about the season from Robin's POV a lot of things she's said have a totally different meaning! It's awesome.
lol, it's almost like when you're re-watching Lost (just to a less obvious extent, clearly).

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]silentwilight
2009-05-22 03:36 am UTC (link)
Wow, this is like best picspam ever.
Your analysis on brotp are spot on. I feel the same way.
Sigh, these two. They make my heart all happy.

Thank you for the picspam :)

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]starryeyedmagic
2009-05-22 05:23 am UTC (link)
Thanks! I love that there's so much deeper meaning with this show and that it really causes you to "think" about things after your first watching!

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]brandyleigh
2009-05-22 03:48 am UTC (link)
Great picspam! And I totally agree with your theory on Robin. I think when they slept together last season, it felt like it *meant* something, but because it's Barney, she would think that it didn't mean anything to him and that she'd be an actual crazy person to even contemplate it. So it's just deny, deny, deny.

+ She's being totally honest here. There is no Mosbying going on. I mean, Ted doesn't even Mosby this awkwardly. ha.
Yeah, I kinda thought this, too. Her body language/tone/demeanor is completely different from when she was Mosbying him on the roof. Plus, like you said, when she says "What?" she's taken aback because she thought they were having an honest conversation, and now he's reverting back to wanting to just be friends. Also, I can totally see her deciding to put herself out there because he was being completely honest and vulnerable, and she knows that he just doesn't do that kind of thing.

Marshall and Lily are precious, and I loved how excited they were when Robin made up her fake B&B story.

I'm going to feel so bad for Ted next season. Hopefully his professional life will be awesome, because it's going to suck watching Marshall/Lily and Barney/Robin when Ted still hasn't found "The One."

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]starryeyedmagic
2009-05-22 05:58 am UTC (link)
Yup, precisely. Barney really seemed to show with the "troubling" line that he can be more than just "Barney". Of course she always knew this, because he does show his vulnerable side from time to time...but for him to really say it like that probably meant a lot to her.

I do worry about Ted too. I mean, even though Barney/Robin won't be all obnoxiously coupley about it or ever make him feel left out, it'd still be weird for Ted just knowing all of his friends have something that he wants so badly. It's funny that Barney and Robin found the kind of love that Ted's been looking for (albeit different in a lot of ways) without even looking for it.
Back in s2 when Barney was the 5th wheel I kind of felt bad for him at times. And he wasn't even looking for a relationship. Putting Ted in that position is a little bit sad.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]barilace
2009-05-22 04:12 am UTC (link)
Professor Ted. *le sigh*

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]starryeyedmagic
2009-05-22 06:00 am UTC (link)
He looks rather dashing next to that chalkboard!

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]deuxcoeurs
2009-05-22 04:59 am UTC (link)
Your picspams rule all and they make my day before it even begins, did you know that? ♥

Um, Professor Mosby! I'm so excited for Ted, he gets to meet the mother (lol, I totally just typed his mother, creepy) in his class soon...ish! He'd be a great professor, I can just see it.

IA with all your thoughts on Robin, that's basically what I think, too. Then again I think being so crazily invested in this pairing, we've just become very, very observant to each and every move/gesture/look/etc etc. Like, when Robin says, "Maybe I do" in the hospital scene, I had to replay it quite a few times but I noticed her lips were actually quivering, like she had to use all her strength to say it and that makes me think... that was her being honest!

Ditto on her line translation at the bar with Marshall/Lily. That's definitely what's on her mind! As I said previously, either people want her to suddenly love him too, or they just didn't buy what she said in the hospital and were kind of pissed that Robin seemed to like him without any build up. I think you just have to look really hard and distinguish when she's saying the truth and when she's Mosby-ing him.

NEVER APOLOGIZE FOR THE AMOUNT OF CAPS. NEVER! I love that first cap when they lunged to each other, guuuh. There's just a whole lot of sexy. Also, Robin after the kiss! She looked breathless, hee.

This is where the fun really starts. I can think of about 30 different hilarious and awesome Barney/Robin storylines off the top of my head that don't involve anything traditional. I think it'll be a new venture for television to have a couple like this.

They'll be the anti-couple.


IA, IA, IA! This is exactly why I love them so much. Oh, all the potential for hilarious storylines! Thanks again for this picspam, I can look at it foreverrrr.

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]starryeyedmagic
2009-05-22 07:01 am UTC (link)
Yes, soon-ish. Sometime within the next 5 years I'm sure, ha! Oh poor Ted. (As much as I love HIMYM I really hope it doesn't go all the way to s9...)

Her lip was quivering! I think it's such a huge deal for her to admit anything like that (even to herself). She was so blank faced when she was Mosbying him at the party because that wasn't real. But her monologue at the hospital totally was, hence the dramatically different body language.

either people want her to suddenly love him too,
This would have been odd. Because that would have required her to be completley aware of her feelings all along and that would have been a little depressing. I mean, Barney at least always had a bit of hope that she might want to be with him. Robin may be afraid of commitment, but she isn't completely opposed to being in a relationship in general. So even though the whole idea of loving Robin scared him he didn't feel...hopeless about it.
However if Robin were consciously crushing on him for over a year? Wow, in a way that'd be almost masochistic of her. ha.

or they just didn't buy what she said in the hospital and were kind of pissed that Robin seemed to like him without any build up.
I just don't buy that Robin is that good of an actor for her mini-monlogue to have been fake, haha.

And I think it makes more sense that there wasn't a lot of build up given her character's tendency to bury things...however, I would have liked a tad more I suppose. But just really little things. Like I would have loved to have seen more of them just hanging out together and bro-ing about. I loved how in "Murtaugh" the Barney/Robin plot wasn't directly addressed but it was actually a huge B/R episode in a way because it showed how perfect they are together and how much fun they can have.
I think if people saw them spending more time together (even if there's no direct mentions of Robin's feelings) they might have been able to accept that she could have had subconscious feelings for him all along.

I CAN'T WAIT FOR ROBIN TO BE PERMANENTLY BREATHLESS NEXT SEASON! Hears to them being totally sexed-out.

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)(Expand)

(no subject) - [info]deuxcoeurs, 2009-05-23 04:25 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]starryeyedmagic, 2009-05-23 05:48 pm UTC (Expand)
(no subject) - [info]deuxcoeurs, 2009-05-23 08:39 pm UTC (Expand)

[info]oktoberskies
2009-05-22 05:43 am UTC (link)
Epic picspam! This episode was all kinds of amazing! <333

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]starryeyedmagic
2009-05-22 07:10 am UTC (link)
Thanks! It really was! Ah, I can't wait until next season! S5 = Barney/Robin hooking up all over the place! :D

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]askfor_me
2009-05-22 06:13 am UTC (link)
being sick sucks so much!! i hope you feel better sooN!

I LOVE YOUR PICSPAM. THE FINALE WAS SO GREAT. I LOVED HOW IT WAS DONE. I CAN'T WAIT FOR S5!

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]starryeyedmagic
2009-05-22 07:11 am UTC (link)
I started feeling a bit better during dinner tonight so I think I'm on the road to recovery. :)

I CAN'T WAIT EITHER! AH I PREDICT LOTS AND LOTS OF BARNEY/ROBIN SEX! Can Barney be over-sexed? I want to find out! :p

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]believeinlife
2009-05-22 02:28 pm UTC (link)
I followed you over here from the Barney/Robin community - I <3 your analysis of the finale! I totally agree with you - I think Robin's always had feelings for Barney that she just ignores b/c it's Barney. And, I also agree with you that she's not Mosbying him after he gives his little speech about wanting the trouble. I thinks she's genuinely confessing how she feels and then she has to lie and say she Mosbyed him because that's what he's expecting from her. It's totally a game between them.
Anyway. /fangirl squealing.

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]starryeyedmagic
2009-05-22 07:19 pm UTC (link)
Yup, it is a game. Always has been. From battleship in "Zip, Zip, Zip" to present day. I can't wait to see how it'll all plays out next year.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]lothl_rien
2009-05-22 02:44 pm UTC (link)
First: I love your works ♥
I realize that about 117 people have already done picspams of this but I just needed to share my own brand of over-analyzing insanity.
it doesn't matter... i saw every picspam LOL
Barney & Robin vs "The Feelings"
i like this title ^^
Even when you're being cute you're being dirty. And that's why I love you.
exactly!
heh, Lily kept this from Marshall for 1 whole day! Good for Lily!
but if the month had 31 days lily maintained the secret for 2 days... unbelivable!
This also reminds me of Phoebe from Friends saying "THIS IS BRAND NEW INFORMATION!" ha.
i thought the same thing =D

I WILL NOT APOLOGIZE FOR THE AMOUNT OF CAPS!
i love you for your kiss rappresentation ♥ it's perfect

"Oh we didn't just make out at the hospital? What?"
LOL

Aw, the little smile in the first cap in the 2nd row
he's so cute ^_^

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]starryeyedmagic
2009-05-22 07:21 pm UTC (link)
Thanks! haha yea, I feel like both of them have totally waged a war against ever having real feelings for each other. Because it CAN'T happen. Except they failed and it did. Woops! ;)

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]xnicholle
2009-05-23 01:12 am UTC (link)
Oh damn, girl! I hope you feel better soon!

uggghhh, barney/robin <3 <3

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]starryeyedmagic
2009-05-23 05:49 pm UTC (link)
Thanks, I'm feeling a bit better!

AH B/R ARE SO EPIC! I can't wait to see all the sex they're going to have next season!

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]justanothergirl
2009-05-23 11:45 pm UTC (link)
Yuck colds. I hope you're feeling better.

This is probably your most epic picspam of the season, but this was the most epic episode Barney/Robin-wise, so. Guh, I love them. Barney's trouble line totally made my heart melt, awww.

I agree, it looks like really far to jump. I was so anxious in those scenes, lol. I think I am afraid of heights. I had to tell myself it was Future!Ted exaggerating or something :P

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]starryeyedmagic
2009-05-25 07:13 am UTC (link)
I am, thanks!

I'm not even afraid of heights but that jump just looks insane. And they're so nonchalant about it. Plus, it's one thing for Marshall to make it since he's kind of tall but Lily...lol. Marshall should have been able to straddle the two buildings for her to make it across!

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]starsfixate
2009-05-24 02:56 am UTC (link)
Ugh, I'm late, BUT YAY THIS PICSPAM IS EPIC. BARNEY/ROBIN. ♥ Your analyzation of Robin's side of this relationship is perfect and I 100% agree with it. I cannot waitttt for next season! And if somehow the show starts screwing things up, I vote that you become a writer because you've really got B/R's realtionship down more than anyone, lol.

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]starryeyedmagic
2009-05-25 07:14 am UTC (link)
HAHA thanks! If only!

This relationship has so much possibility to be something new and different! I really hope they do it right! But so far, so good!

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]tunaeverynight
2009-05-24 05:40 am UTC (link)
FEEL BETTER!

And holy shit, this picspam makes me desperately want to watch HIMYM now. I love Barney and Robin from the earlier episodes, and I'm so eager to see them as a couple! This is so pretty!

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]starryeyedmagic
2009-05-25 07:15 am UTC (link)
I can't wait to hear your thoughts as soon as you catch up! :D

(Reply to this) (Parent)


(73 comments) - (Post a new comment)

Page 1 of 2
<<[1] [2] >>

Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…